ALL we sell, with tasting notes for mostSearch our web site by keyword. Includes the Usenet Wine FAQALL we sell, with tasting notes for mostSome of our favorite linksHow to get here from there. Highway condition links.An archive of the Santa Barbara Independent's own GRAPEVINE local wine columnWining, dining, touring, weather and more. The Definitive Guide to Tasting Wine in Santa Barbara County. Complete list of wineriesOur own great Emporium events as well as links to local area wine eventsOur line-up of spirits, definition of word related to spirits, information on producers and more
Wines, wine tastings, history, neat info on wineries and winemakers and more
The Los Olivos Wine & Spirits Emporium. Experts in County of Santa Barbara Wine and Central Coast Wine
 
Clickable Image  

The Bernard Roth Archives

The Los Olivos Wine & Spirits Emporium presents notes of Bernard Roth who always has something to say, particularly about wine and food.

We are happy that Bernard, who has sampled so many wines, has shared his notes with us. We do have, or have had for sale a few of the wines Bernard writes about, and we include a link to our stock page whenever it is a producer we carry (but since the stock page is kept up-to-date and the wines are sold, don't expect any but the newest of wines to show up in our stock!). Mostly though, since we specialize in County of Santa Barbara Wine and Central Coast Wine, we don't carry a lot of the wines Bernard writes about. But we think it is important that you be able to have an idea what they're like in case you are planning to buy some somewhere, or have them in your own collection. Enjoy.

Here are Bernard's notes from September 30, 1998:

Birthday Dinner

I enjoyed my birthday dinner (a couple days prematurely) Friday night at Citronelle in Santa Barbara. Citronelle is French-accented California cuisine, owned by Michel Richard. The chef de cuisine is Felicien Cueff.  Felicien prepared a special meal for us, described below with the wines.  I did not take notes because I did not care to be encumbered during the meal. What follows is from memory:
Artichoke Terrine on Tomato Coulis with Dressed Greens 
Smoked Salmon and Beluga Caviar with Chive Creme Fraiche

94 Louis Latour Puligny-Montrachet--Lighter style edition of this Burgundy, reflecting the vintage. Delicate, properly balanced with steely minerality, just enough fruit and fine acidity. Decent though not particularly long finish. This went really well with the Caviar and Salmon, as the weight of this wine exhibited similarities to a fine Blancs des Blancs Champagne.  Latour did not coax quite the depth or length from their AC P-M as did  Sauzet in the same vintage. Drink over the next 2 years. My rating: 89.

Black Sesame Crusted Rare Ahi with Mushroom Ragout

89 A. Rousseau Gevrey-Chambertin Clos St. Jacques Premier Cru--Light brick red with no browning in the rim. Gorgeous bouquet of earthy, barnyardy aromas atop dried fruit and red currants. Almost silky textured, but given more dimension by fairly high acidity and a slight tannic grip. Flavor profile in tune with the bouquet, a hint of sweetness in the fruit keeps the wine fresh tasting, though it is fully mature now. This is the kind of terroir driven wine smart CA pinot noir makers have given up trying to copy. This went well with the tuna by itself, but the accompanying ragout was a tad over-salted to match the elegance of the wine. 93

This next wine was given to me as a gift by one of my friends at the dinner.  It came wrapped in silver foil and I decided I'd try to guess the wine. The only hints were: It was a Burgundy shaped bottle and it had been purchased at the Wine Cask. The waiter poured everybody double blind (even the friend, who's wife bought it, didn't know what it was). The color was inky purple and one whiff gave the wine away. Both Seth and I immediately looked at each other and nodded in agreement that we knew this wine was...

96 Ojai Pinot Noir Pisoni--Inky purple. Very forward, huge nose of black berry, lavender, some toasty oak, yet more black fruit, and some earthy, mushroomy complexity. WHAT A MONSTER! Very dense, very concentrated, highly extracted, incredible fruit bomb. Not necessarily pleasant to drink right now. Very tannic and not really in focus, yet impressive. Hard to match to food, though this stood up better to the mushroom ragout than did the Rousseau. Finish is extremely long driven by the tannins and extract.  Verging on monumental, though I'd reserve that label for a wine with a better track record. There's no telling how this wine will age. Last year's Ojai version, called "Benjamin Lorenzo", fell apart after a year in bottle, undergoing secondary fermentation that killed the wine. Hopefull this wine will not meet that fate because it will need a lon-n-ng time to come around, unless, of course you prefer palate-destroying wines and infanticide. For now, I'd rate the wine 94+ based on potential, though it drinks less well.

Rare Lamb Loin with an Herb Crust of Eggplant, Zucchini and Ground Lamb on a Reduction Sauce and Tuile Basket with Baby Pattypan Squash and Asparagus

85 Vega Sicilia Unico--Dark violet. Very seductive bouquet that first grabs you with earthy, gamy aromas, then unleashed secondary aromas of cassis, lilacs, and pomegranate. Nose continues to evolve over the course. In the mouth this is utter sensual pleasure. Silky, refined, elegant, but with a power and depth that causes one to pause and disengage from the rest of the dinner party and focus on the wine. Like Ch. Margaux in a top vintage.  Total harmony in a wine, sexy, and living up to the reputation this wine has earned. Triple WOW! Oh, and by the way, the lamb was flavored in a way that reminded me of Middle Eastern ground lamb skewers, and similar to Moorish influenced Spanish cuisine. The food-wine match was perfect! The 85 Unico may gain from a few more years of bottle age, and should last 10-15 years. It is definitely worth the splurge. 95+

78 Silver Oak Alexander Valley Cab--Youthfully dark color. Fine nose with cassis and black cherry and oak. Retaining its fruit very well, tannins are still very noticeable, but still out of focus on the finish. Certainly not capable of following the Unico, but it did go nicely with the lamb.  Should last another 10 years. A generous 92 points.

Seven Dessert for Seven People. Michel Richard makes the best desserts in Southern California. We had: Tower of Filo layers with Whipped Cream, Raspberries, and a top layer of Custard Creme, served on Raspberry Coulis; Lemon Tart with Lemon Sauce; Molten Chocolate Torte; a Pear Pastry with some kind of Cream and pear sauce; some kind of chocolate ice cream dessert;  Chocolate Creme Brulee; and Michel's signature dessert--Caramel Napolean.

Ordered off the wine list: 95 Baumard Quarts de Chaumes--I've commented on this several times. If you've had the 96, kick that up a notch. Beautiful fruity, floral nose with ample layers of complexity. Silky, yet syrupy, in the mouth. Lots of sugar supported by incredible acidity. Perfect balance, long on flavor, very long finish.  A truly masterful expression of the greatness of chenin blanc. This is kick-ass dessert wine that has few equals in the world. 98 


Return to the Bernard Roth Archive Index